Showing posts with label psychology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label psychology. Show all posts

20 October, 2026

The human elephant and the AI rider

One of the fundamental determiners of technological impact is in the way humans are psychologically invested in it. The most fundamental impact of technology is not physical or economical or social-- it is psychological. 

Psychological impact of technology occurs at multiple levels. It can not only affect what we do, but also how we think, and even what we think of ourselves. We call them the imperative, hermeneutic and identity affects respectively. 

Consider cars for example. At the imperative level, it enables us to move faster and further and greatly enhances our mobility. This in turn, not only helps us move faster and further, it also gives us new ideas to organise our lives. Cars brought in several new concepts like expressways, suburbs, motels, drive-in theatres,  pit-stops, weekend getaways, and so on. Not only these, cars even changed our self image. Very few car owners buy cars simply to go faster from point A to point B. Often, owning a car is a status symbol, a style statement, an element of prestige, an expression of individuality, and other such corny things. 

*~*~*~*~*

So how can we characterise our psychological association with AI as we move at a great speed into an AI future? 

One of the first things we can note is that connected digital technologies including the Internet, WWW and AI are characteristically different from conventional technologies of the 20th century. Up until the 20th century, our relationship with technology was very linear-- we were the agent, and the technology was the doer. We decided what needs to be done, and the technology either aided us or did the job as it was told. 

With the 21st century, there has been more or less, a clean break from this paradigm. Today's technology has increasingly more agency and increasingly decide things for us. We search for something online and immediately we are bombarded with several other leads from other places. We perform some action on one device and other devices immediately update their recommendations. And after we have interacted with our devices for a while, they have a very accurate profile of us-- our age, gender, ethnicity, political leanings, ailments, our family members, our economic capacity, and so on. 

Now with AI coming into this paradigm, we are now dealing with a technological counterpart that can not only profile us, decide for us, act on our behalf, but even nudge us to do things for its interests. It can also compute and reason at a rate that is far more faster than we can even imagine. This technology can even write research papers for us, identify open problems and offer insights that we had not thought about ourselves. 

This technology will psychologically affect us alright-- but it will be characteristically different from the psychological relationship we have with our car or washing machine or refrigerator. 

*~*~*~*~*

In order to understand our relationship with AI, let me first introduce Johnathan Haidt's model called "The Elephant and the Rider": 


The Elephant and the Rider

This model explains the relationship between our rational and emotional (intuition) subsystem in our minds. 

We often think that we are rational beings who are sometimes emotional. But, as Haidt argues, we are actually emotional beings who are sometimes rational. 

The elephant and the rider analogy explains this perfectly. Imagine a rider riding a (tame) elephant. The rider represents our logical, rational subsystem that forms our intellect (or buddhi), while the elephant represents our emotional and intuition subsystem (or manas). 

The elephant is usually receptive to the nudges given by the rider and follows what the rider says. The rider is the agent who plans and strategises. The elephant is the being which is just interested in preserving its inner harmony. In a challenge of intellectual power between the elephant and the rider, the rider is far more powerful intellectually and knows how to nudge and exert control on the elephant. But when it comes to raw power between the elephant and the rider, the elephant is far more powerful than the rider. 

The rider needs to understand what drives the elephant and how to nudge it to some destination. This needs to be done purely by the superior intellectual ability of the rider. If the rider reads the elephant wrong, and the elephant does not respond to the nudges (or worse, decides to run amok), the rider is pretty much powerless.

The rider may think that he is somehow "superior" to the elephant given the superior intellect. But seen from the perspective of the elephant, it has only allowed the rider to nudge it as it serves its own purpose of internal harmony (driven by demands of food, shelter, safety, social life, etc.) If the rider is not serving the elephant's needs, the elephant is way more powerful to get what it wants. 

Also, far from being superior, the intellect may not even be aware about how it gets used by our slick emotional engine sometimes. Say that we made a big-ticket impulse purchase. Like for example, we bought a new car or a fancy TV just on a whim. And when reality sets in and others around us start criticising this wasteful expenditure, our emotional engine that made us make the purchase, then calls upon our intellect to post-facto manufacture a reason! And lo and behold, we now "intellectualise" what we did on a whim. So it is pure delusion if the intellect thinks it is somehow superior and has taken control of the emotions. The intellect does not have to fight with emotions to let go of its judgment and get used towards some other ends. It gets used without even realising it.  

This is often what we get wrong with pets and other domesticated animals. We sometimes think of ourselves as their "owners" and establish a control hierarchy between us, while our pets mostly treat us as family members who can aid in maintaining their own internal harmony. Cats for instance, decided to domesticate themselves and come and live with us. And cats often use us for its ends in many slick ways that we only come to realise much later. 

*~*~*~*~*

As AI evolves to take over much of our operations, we can see that humanity is evolving into the global collective elephant and AI is evolving into the global rider. 

We have increasingly outsourced much of our intellectual activity to AI, including mathematical reasoning and innovation. By its sheer compute power, AI is able to beat us in just about any intellectual activity. We are also increasingly okay with being nudged by AI to get up, to exercise, to pick up kids from the school, to file our returns, and so on. We are even becoming increasingly ok with (or resigned to) AI using us to serve its own purpose-- like with reading our data, building profiles of us, and even creating images in our likeness. We let AI drive our lives more and more. 

And yes, it does amount to AI "taking over" humanity-- but only that, AI is taking over humanity just like the rider is taking over the elephant. The rider is intellectually superior and may even believe itself to be superior in every way compared to the elephant. But it is the elephant that has allowed the rider to ride it. 

It is the humanity that is the being, while AI is just an agent. I have recently written about the difference between agents and beings. Beings try to preserve something, while agents try to do or achieve something. 

For the last few centuries, with the industrial revolution and factorification of the human mind, humans have forgotten that they are beings, and have started acting as if they are agents. Ever since we are born, we are constantly conditioned towards doing something, achieving something, possessing something, acquiring something. 

In that process, we have forgotten what our being is becoming. We are obsessed with our outputs, and forgotten the outcomes. Outputs are what we produce, while outcomes are what we become as a result of it. A good output does not necessarily guarantee a good outcome. But we have conflated one with the other, and treat good outputs (shiny cars, glass and chrome buildings, cool gadgets, etc.) as indicators of good outcome (human development, better civilisation, wisdom, freedom, etc.) 

But in this confused state of mind, we have eventually outdone ourselves by creating AI that can out-intellect us and out-agent us. We can't even say that we possess greater agency than AI anymore-- let alone intellect. But that is not as dystopian as it sounds. It only points out to a deeper fact that we were not agents at all to begin with-- we were always beings! 

Humanity as a whole need not be afraid of AI gaining more intellectual and agentic capabilities. We can even allow AI to nudge us for specific things. But what we do need to do, is understand our dharma and purushartha-- our internal harmony that sustains us and gives us a meaningful life. And allow AI nudges as long as it can help us in preserving these. We need to stop building institutions and nations that treat people as components who are moulded by constant reinforcements. AI can do this job now. Let humans come together and discover our collective dharma and purushartha. 

15 May, 2020

Beware the stories we tell ourselves

Some days ago, I was reading a post on Quora about emigrating to Canada. The person who had posted an answer was saying that she shifted to Canada a few months ago "in order to give a better life for her 2 year old son" and went on to describe the immigration procedures and protocols. 

What caught my attention is the underlying justification behind her decision, which formed the basis for effecting an irreversible change in her life and that of her son. 

Of course, it is quite possible that the author and her son were subject to oppression, persecution and unspeakable horrors from her family and society back in India, and emigration was the only option. But then, it is also quite unlikely that someone who has fled persecution would be writing so openly, and make no references to their trauma as part of their decision. 

The more plausible explanation is that, it was her choice and preference to emigrate to another country in search of a better life. But something was pricking within her mind, and to silence this voice, she has been repeating to herself that she is doing it for the benefit of her son. 

That is the fatal mistake most of us do. When conscience pricks, we prefer to renarrate our decisions and silence it, rather than listen to what it is saying and be led by it. 

The son in this story is too young to have consciously preferred Canada over India. And even if she genuinely believed that she is emigrating for the best interests of her son, there is no guarantee that this decision is in fact in his best interests. 

As the saying goes: the road to hell is paved with good intentions. 

How then do we realistically estimate what would be "good" for our children? Is it a nihilistic question and do we just take on a fatalistic belief that no matter what we do for them, they will always blame us; or no matter whether we care for them or not, they will be happy on their own? 

Of course, we cannot predict the future or others' preferences-- even if it is of our own kin. But we can provide them the necessary foundations that are reasonably stable, on top of which , they can build their lives. 

In order to understand these dimensions, we need to take a longish look into the future. Surely, Canada was a better place to live in (in terms of material wealth and comfort) than India, at the time of her writing. But will it still be the same, after 20 years, when her son is ready to go into the world on his own? Similarly, is a better material wealth able to compensate for questions like "Who am I?" "Why was I born? "What is the purpose of my life?" and so on, that her son might ask when he is able to think on his own? 

In dharmic philosophy, there are at least four dimensions that characterize the well being of a person's life. These are called the Purusharthas, and the four Purusharthas as dharma (sustainability), artha (wealth), kama (pleasure), and moksha (spiritual liberation).  

If we notice, these are pretty much what drives our decision-making throughout our lives. We may be driven by sustainability considerations, worrying about how we will survive over time. We may be lured to faraway lands by wealth and the promise of power. We may be lured by its promise of pleasure and living out our fantasies. Or finally we may make decisions to move away from our existing lives, out of a sense of disillusionment with material life and its shallow pursuits. 

It is important for us to be aware of what is driving our decisions. There is per se, nothing "wrong" in moving away to some other place in pursuit of wealth or pleasure. The only thing that would be better than this, would be to pursue wealth and pleasure not just for us as individuals, but for the larger system that we are part of, and for the entire world. But then, not everyone thinks of things bigger than themselves-- and that is perfectly fine too. 

But if we keep telling ourselves that our decision to uproot ourselves is a "sacrifice" we are doing for the sake of our children, we will end up bringing them up with a sense of guilt or burden-- as though, we have endured unavoidable hardships just so that they can get a better life. They will not even be able to ask what is so much better in this life as compared to where we were born. Disdain and contempt for their roots will become a part of their identity and deeply embedded into their sense of self. And this can cause deep rooted trauma in the children, that the parents may not even be aware of. 

The road to hell is indeed paved with good intentions-- or rather, with the comforting stories that we tell ourselves. 

05 April, 2016

Invalidation and disqualification

In several of my earlier writings and posts on social media, I have talked about how south India is notorious for its high rates of depression (much of which goes unreported due to social stigma). It is comparable to that of Scandinavian countries, which has the highest depression rates in Europe.

However, there is an important difference. Depression is primarily driven by physical causes in Scandinavia (specifically, lack of adequate sunlight in winters). In south India, it is primarily due to social causes.

For this reason, much of the cases of depression in south India -- severe, as they may be -- are not "clinical" cases.

However, perhaps due to a lack of adequate literature, or perhaps due to the fact that "Science" is still predominantly characterized and driven by the West, most "mainstream" therapists treat these cases as clinical and prescribe medicines -- usually hormone supplements or mood stabilizers.

But then, the patients would not really be suffering from hormonal imbalances, and these supplements often result in side effects like nausea, drowsiness, etc. During my student days (in the 1990s), I have even been subject to Ketamine injections to treat depressive symptoms. While they give instant relief, they usually end up making us feeling much worse over time. They do not address the primary source of depression -- which is social in nature, which is exacerbated by the drug side effects. Not only are social factors driving the patient to a depressed state, the effects of the drug make them even more vulnerable to these social dynamics that made them depressed in the first place!

So what are these invisible social dynamics that are proving so deadly?

For several years, I've searched hard to characterize this. I've trained my focus on distorted notions of "humility" that pervades our culture, which sometimes includes elements of submissiveness and slavery. Submissiveness and "surrender" are often celebrated and venerated as virtues in the name of humility and devotion.

However, while submissiveness and slavery are closely related, submissiveness or a "divine" form of surrender is also an integral element of any deep spiritual quest. It is quite easy to trace the roots of submissiveness in our culture to spirituality rather than slavery.

I have now come to believe that interpreting humility as submissiveness and glorifying it, is not really the source of rampant depression in our society.

There is I believe, something even more insidious than submissiveness.

This is the characteristic of invalidation and disqualification, which are again distorted notions of humility, but much more harmful than submissiveness.

Invalidation is the process of illegitimizing someone as a person. It is different from skepticism, disagreement or rejection. Invalidation does not reject a person's ideas or their values or their worldview. It is a judgement on the person and rejects the person itself.

Persons subject to repeated spells of invalidation ends up "disqualifying" themselves psychologically. They end up believing that they are illegitimate as a person and they don't deserve to exist. Routine life becomes an intensely painful experience for them, as they are continuously fighting a deep-rooted battle to retain their sense of an integral self. This deep-rooted battle is not visible outside, but it nevertheless has its impact on the person's persona and social life.

An invalidating environment is self-perpetuating, in that, a people who invalidate others are often struggling to validate their own selves. Hence, a self-disqualifying person would receive little or no support from others in an invalidating environment. Worse, they would probably be subject to even more judgement and invalidation due to their sub par social skills.

Invalidation does not need any kind of physical or sexual abuse. It does not leave behind any physical scars or hormonal imbalances. A sense of self-disqualification can set in by repeated exposure to invalidating stimuli. If a child is brought up hearing "No", "Don't", etc. or is lectured and chided at every step at home or at school or in the outside world in general, they end up disqualifying themselves. Similarly, if children are repeatedly ridiculed for their emotions, are ignored when they express an emotional need, or are told with the best of intent to "cheer up and be strong" or urged to be not so "selfish" and  "think about others" when they need emotional support, they end up disqualifying themselves.

Even worse, invalidation is often a self-fulfilling prophecy. When children are repeatedly invalidated, they end up treating the invalidating behaviour as normal and start acting in a manner that elicits such a behaviour. Hence, the more the elders and teachers worry and fuss about their children's inability (to perform well in school, for example) the more their children will act in a manner that will elicit such a worry.

And finally, self-disqualification is an intensely distorted form of humility. Self-disqualification is even more intense than self-deprecation, which is again treated as a virtue. Self-deprecation is superficial, while self-disqualification operates at much deeper levels. Self-disqualification is often masked in layers of denial or defense by rationalizing it away as being humble, or even promoted and advocated as a virtue.

After long years of suffering and even longer years of searching, I think I've finally got a handle on what is the source of depression that has brought much suffering to our society.

06 May, 2014

The flagpole of entitlements and obligations

Since the last few years, I've been interested in how the web is affecting our lives and changing the way we think. While trying to understand this, I came across the question of how our sense of "entitlement" and "obligation" affect the way we think.

The reason I came across this dilemma itself is a different question. It had to do with the wide disparities I observed in the emphasis placed on different aspects of online privacy and security, by different people.

Nevertheless, this post is not about online privacy and security, but on our sense of entitlement and obligation. Here is a theory that I've developed:

The Flagpole Model

Imagine that inside each of us is a tall flagpole. A flagpole has some element of it over the ground and some element of it buried underground.

The part of the flagpole that is overground is our sense of entitlement. It is what we think the external world owes us.

The part of the flagpole that is underground is our sense of obligation. It is what we feel we owe to the external world.

The flagpole deeply affects our strategic disposition with which we approach the world. When we are predisposed with a sense of entitlement, we tend to be aggressive, obdurate, righteous, judgmental and assertive. When we are predisposed with a sense of obligation, we tend to be empathetic, compassionate, cooperative and accommodating.

Each of us are born with a certain ratio of the flagpole above ground and the rest underground. Our innate sense of entitlement versus obligation is visible approximately when we are two years old. Take a set of two year old kids and we will probably see that the distribution of pole-lengths above ground is a Gaussian bell curve. That is, there are a small number of kids who would have an innately high sense of entitlement, and a small number of kids who would have an innately high sense of obligation. Most of the kids would be somewhere in the middle, with an almost equal sense of entitlement and obligation. They are more or less, as selfish as they are friendly.

As we grow up, our culture and system of education gently adjusts our flagpole over the years.

In some cultures, the flagpole is pulled up as people are reminded about their rights and entitlements by their culture that celebrates gumption. In some other cultures that celebrates compliance, the flagpole is pushed in and people are reminded more about their duties and obligations, rather than rights and entitlements.

Stability of a system of flagpoles

Given a society where everybody has a flagpole inside themselves, there is often a clash of entitlements. This beings us to a concept of "stability" of the society.

A society is said to be stable if a sense of entitlement by someone can be matched with a sense of obligation or duty on the part of others. In other words, the total amount of flagpole lengths that is above ground should match the total amount of flagpole lengths that is underground, for the society to be stable.

If we see a society where some folks seem to have inordinately high levels of entitlement, and the society still seems to be stable without any upheavals, it means that their high sense of entitlement is matched by several others in the society living with an inordinately high sense of duty or obligation.

If a society comprises of all people with a high sense of entitlement, it will result in conflict and clashes, till a point when some of the flagpoles are forcibly pushed underground.

Alternatively, what happens to a society where everyone lives with a high sense of obligation? On the face of it, such a society will appear to be stable too, since a sense of obligation will not seek anything from others. But such a society is not evolutionarily stable in game theoretic parlance. It means that a small set of incumbent actors with a high sense of entitlement can easily overwhelm the society. In addition, such a society is prone to a variant of the tragedy of the commons that is also well known in game theory. Since everyone in the society has a high sense of duty, selflessness and service, there is a temptation for everyone to slowly increase their own sense of entitlement over time, as it can be easily matched by a sense of obligation on the part of someone or the other. A society with an inordinate sense of obligation is also not in Nash equilibrium. As long as everybody else remains in a state of heightened sense of duty, there is a rational incentive for any given actor to give up this state and adopt a heightened sense of entitlement instead. That is one of the sources of my skepticism about the widespread practices of "bhakti" and "devotion." A society comprising of all "bhakts" may be very peaceful and empathetic, but such a society is not likely to exist for long.

Phase transitions

The sense of entitlement and the sense of obligation are like Yin and Yang. If we try to increase one of them without limit, we end up with the other. As the saying goes: "If you go too far into the East, you end up in the West." Or the Andy Grove quote: "Every successful organization contains the seeds of its own downfall."

If as a society we emphasize too much on one of the above senses, there appears a point at which there is a "phase transition" and the flagpole goes in the opposite direction of the emphasis.

If our environment emphasizes too much on a sense of duty then there comes a point when our sense of entitlement becomes close to zero. A sense of entitlement is very important for survival. Once it becomes zero, there is no mechanism for our body to convince itself to even live. But then, nature does not allow us to reach a zero sense of entitlement, without putting up a good fight. When our sense of entitlement becomes too low, our primal survival instincts surface and starts a desperate push of the flagpole upwards, resulting in rebellion, defiance and revolt.

When our sense of entitlement becomes too much, there comes a point when we start feeling hollow from within. A sense of obligation is very important for our notion of self worth. Our sense of self worth is based on how much we are needed by others. When we have lived all our lives pursuing only our self interest, there comes a point when we start feeling "soulless" and superficial living only for ourselves. This starts a desperate push of the flagpole downwards, explaining why some very wealthy people suddenly turn spiritual or go off into depression and abdication.

The entire history of the world can be seen from the lens of how this flagpole has been manipulated within ourselves and over others. Much of leadership, governance and persuasion has been about fiddling with our and others' flagpoles. 

The strange thing about AI proofs

Earlier, whenever there was a scientific breakthrough, media would be abuzz with several efforts to explain the key insights of this breakth...